6 Comments
User's avatar
Samuel Western's avatar

Fine piece, John. Thanks for reminding us how we get seduced by the idea of something, not necessarily the reality.

Expand full comment
Lee Nellis's avatar

I suppose a little plaque would blend nicely into the Brown Palace. But who would even know to look for it? A very small group of cognoscenti, I guess.

As for the tree, the Museum could do something with it. And given the odd internal contradictions of Wyoming, it might be great. But I'd prefer they leave that tree where it is.

As for really honoring wilderness, I think we mostly do that by going. But as I age, I fear its going to have to be ok to drive to the trailhead and wave. Beyond the geography of it, though, I think the ongoing conversation is also, in part, a tribute.

Expand full comment
John Clayton's avatar

and maybe even ongoing conversations about where the tributes should be...

Expand full comment
Lee Nellis's avatar

This prompted me to think of the Mather plaques. Something in every wilderness? But instead of easy to find (usually), in a remote spot like Ferry Lake or Hawk’s Rest?

I suppose that would trigger a bucket list game in some people, but I could live with that.

What would the plaque say?

Expand full comment
John Clayton's avatar

The Mather plaques! (Great history here: https://www.nationalparkstraveler.org/2019/03/stephen-mather-memorial-plaques). It strikes me that there are 3 ways we can tell stories about wilderness: through place (as I discussed in this essay), people (Mather... Zahniser or Marshall?), or science (which may be the most admirable but least accessible).

Expand full comment
Lee Nellis's avatar

Thanks for the link!

Expand full comment